Mexitaly Restaurant | York, Pennsylvania

Mexitaly!
Complete Menu
Mexico

Portable Burritos

Portable Burritos are available with your choice of Pork Carnitas, Southwest Steak, Chipotle Chicken, Chorizo (Mexican Sausage), Seasoned Ground Beef. We also offer Veggie and Bean Burritos. Each burrito includes a single complimentary housemade hot sauce or try a sample flight of each of our 5 flavors for an additional 2.99! Most burritos are available in a more compact Poco version for smaller appetites!

The Big Burrito
Rice, beans and choice of meat with sour cream, salsa and cheese.
Big... 6.99
Poco... 4.99
California Steak Burrito
Southwestern seasoned steak, french fries, cheese, pico, guacamole and sour cream.
Big... 8.99
Poco... 6.99
The Monster Burrito
The Big Burrito (above) with guacamole added.
Big... 7.99
Poco... 5.99
The Big Bean Burrito
Rice, beans, salsa, sour cream and cheese.
Big... 4.99
Poco... 3.99
The Fajita Burrito
The Monster Burrito (above) with roasted peppers, onions and cheese added.
Big... 8.99
Poco... 6.99
The Monster Bean Burrito
The Big Bean Burrito (above) with extra cheese and guacamole.
Big... 5.99
Poco... 4.99
The Big Fish Burrito
Grilled chipotle seasoned salmon, rice, beans, sour cream, cheese and guacamole.
Big... 10.99
Poco... Not Available
The BBQ Burrito
Rice, beans, BBQ sauce, sour cream, cheese and your choice of meat (excludes seafood).
Big... 6.99
Poco... 4.99
The Veggie Burrito
Grilled eggplant, onions, zucchini, roasted peppers, rice, beans, cheese, sour cream, salsa, and guacamole.
Big... 7.99
Poco... 5.99
Roasted Root Veggie Burrito
Oven roasted red potatoes, parsnip, carrots, and onion with salsa, sour cream, rice, beans, cheese and guacamole.
Big... 7.99
Poco... 5.99

Tacorito
Everything that is normally in our flavorful tacos, except wrapped up as a burrito. Your choice of standard meat; with cheese, sour cream, lettuce, pico de gallo, and corn chips.
Big... 6.99
Poco... 4.99
The Seafood Burrito
Spicy seared chipotle seasoned shrimp and scallops, rice, beans, salsa, sour cream, cheese & guacamole.
Big... 10.99
Poco... Not Available
Add Steak... 1.00
Add Guacamole for 1.00
Add Extra Meat for 1.50
Add Double Meat for 3.00
Add French Fries IN THE BURRITO for 1.00
 

Hard or Soft Shell Tacos

In your choice of hard or soft shells. Dressed with pico de gallo, sour cream, lettuce and cheese. Gluten-free.

Seasoned Ground Beef Tacos
3 of Same Variety
6.99

Platter with Rice & Beans
8.99

Chorizo (Mexican Sausage) Tacos
3 of Same Variety
6.99

Platter with Rice & Beans
8.99
Southwestern Steak Tacos
3 of Same Variety
6.99

Platter with Rice & Beans
8.99
Pork Carnitas Tacos
3 of Same Variety
6.99

Platter with Rice & Beans
8.99
Chipotle Chicken Tacos
3 of Same Variety
6.99

Platter with Rice & Beans
8.99
Fish (Tilapia) Tacos
3 of Same Variety
7.99

Platter with Rice & Beans
9.99

Chimichangas

Chimichangas are served platter style with seasoned rice. Topped with salsa, sour cream, and guacamole. Choose from pork carnitas, Southwest chicken, Chipotle chicken, seasoned ground beef, or housemade Chorizo (Mexican sausage).

Chimichanga
Stuffed pocket of dough with your choice of meat with beans, topped with salsa, sour cream, guacamole and cheese.
13.99
 
Salmon Chimichanga
Stuffed pocket filled with seared salmon and beans, topped with salsa, sour cream, guacamole and cheese.
16.99
Seafood Chimichanga
Stuffed pocket filled with shrimp and scallops and beans, topped with salsa, sour cream, guacamole and cheese.
16.99

Enchiladas

Enchiladas are served platter style with seasoned rice, beans and guacamole. Choose between housemade ranchero (red) sauce or housemade tomatillo (green) sauce and your choice of meat including pork carnitas, Southwest steak, Chipotle chicken, seasoned ground beef, or housemade Chorizo (Mexican sausage).

Enchiladas
Choice of meat and sauce, topped with queso fresco cheese and sour cream. Served with rice, beans and guacamole.
13.99
 
Salmon Enchiladas
Seared seasoned salmon with your choice of red or green sauce, topped with queso fresco cheese and sour cream. Served with seasoned rice, beans and guacamole.
16.99
Seafood Enchiladas
Seared shrimp and scallops with your choice of red or green sauce, topped with queso fresco cheese and sour cream. Served with seasoned rice, beans and guacamole.
16.99

Quesadillas

The Mexican grilled cheese. Add your choice of flame grilled meat with salsa and sour cream. Meat varieties now have more meat. Add roasted onions or roasted peppers for 50 cents each.

Cheesy Quesadilla
A blend of Jack and Cheddar cheese with sour cream and freshly made salsa grilled inside a flour tortilla.
5.99
Rice & Beans Quesadilla
A blend of Jack and Cheddar cheese, our original Rice & Beans, sour cream and freshly made salsa grilled inside a flour tortilla.
6.99
Meaty Quesadilla
With your choice of Chipotle Chicken, Seasoned Ground Beef, Pork Carnitas, Chorizo, or Southwestern Steak, a blend of Jack and Cheddar cheeses, salsa and sour cream.
8.99
Italian Quesadilla
Your choice of pepperoni, Italian sausage, o meatball with marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese.
7.99
Seafood Quesadilla
With seared Chipotle Shrimp and Scallops, a blend of Jack and Cheddar cheeses, salsa and sour cream.
10.99
Salmon Quesadilla
With seared Salmon, a blend of Jack and Cheddar cheeses, salsa and sour cream.
10.99
Roasted Root Veggie Quesadilla
Oven roasted red potatoes, parsnip, carrots, and onion with salsa, sour cream, rice, beans, cheese and guacamole.
8.99
Grilled Veggie Quesadilla
Zucchini, eggplant, onions, peppers and beans served with salsa, sour cream and guacamole.
8.99

Taco Salads

In an edible hard tortilla bowl. Made with cheese, beans, salsa, sour cream and guacamole. Available gluten-free.

Chipotle Chicken
Taco Salad
Iceberg lettuce, cheese, beans, salsa, sour cream & guacamole with chipotle chicken.
8.99
Carnitas Pork
Taco Salad
Iceberg lettuce, cheese, beans, salsa, sour cream & guacamole with carnitas pork.
8.99
Seasoned Ground Beef
Taco Salad
Iceberg lettuce, cheese, beans, salsa, sour cream & guacamole with seasoned ground beef.
8.99
Shrimp and Scallops
Taco Salad
Iceberg lettuce, cheese, beans, salsa, sour cream & freshly prepared guacamole with chipotle seared shrimp and scallops.
10.99
Southwestern Steak
Taco Salad

Iceberg lettuce, cheese, beans, salsa, sour cream & guacamole with Southwestern seasoned steak.
9.99
Seared Salmon
Taco Salad
Iceberg lettuce, cheese, beans, salsa, sour cream & freshly prepared guacamole with seared salmon.
10.99

Side Dishes

Salsa
A mild traditional salsa created from scratch with fresh ingredients.
.99
Pico De Gallo
A chunky fresh salsa with diced tomatoes, red onions & cilantro.
1.99
Guacamole
Many say it's the finest in York.
2.99
Sour Cream
An excellent finishing touch.
.50
Tortilla Chips
Deep fried corn tortilla chips made daily right here in our kitchen.
.99
Rice and Beans
A hefty side serving of our traditionally seasoned Mexican rice with our flavorful blend of non-refried, whole black and pinto beans.
3.99
Seasoned Rice
A hefty side serving of our traditionally seasoned Mexican rice.
1.99
Beans
A flavorful blend of whole black and pinto beans... not refried. A hefty side serving.
2.99
Fresh Cut Fries
American style, made with fresh cut potatoes, for those who can't live without them.
4.99
Mexican Fries
Slightly spicy seasoned fries made with fresh cut potatoes.
4.99
Cheese Fries
From fresh cut potatoes, served with a side of our homemade queso dipping sauce.
5.99

Cheese Nachos
Served with salsa and homemade queso sauce.
4.99
Nachos Supreme
Your choice of Seasoned Ground Beef or Chorizo, with beans, cheese, salsa and sour cream.
8.99

Housemade Soups

Our housemade soups are always popular.

Bean Soup
Freshly prepared on premises with the highest quality ingredients.
3.99
Bean Soup Supreme
Freshly prepared on premises with the highest quality ingredients. Topped with cheese, sour cream, cilantro, onion, and chips.
4.99

Desserts

Cinnamon Sticks
Cinnamon sugar coated deep fried dough.
4.99
Sopapillas
Deep fried flour tortilla chips coated in cinnamon sugar and drizzled with honey.
4.99

Fresh Brewed Hot Sauces

If you love our freshly brewed hot sauces and want some extra to keep at the homestead, we have all of our primo varieties available for purchase in larger "take-home" sizes. Our hand crafted hot sauces clearly illustrate the difference between store bought brands and those that are freshly crafted from prime ingredients.

Roasted Cherry Pepper
Salsa

Freshly prepared on premises with the highest quality ingredients.
4 Ounces: 1.99
12 Ounces: 5.95
Chipotle
Salsa

Freshly prepared on premises with the highest quality ingredients.
4 Ounces: 1.99
12 Ounces: 5.95

El Diablo
Salsa

Freshly prepared on premises with the highest quality ingredients.
4 Ounces: 1.99
12 Ounces: 5.95
Jalapeno
Salsa

Freshly prepared on premises with the highest quality ingredients.
4 Ounces: 1.99
12 Ounces: 5.95
Mango Habanero
Salsa

Freshly prepared on premises with the highest quality ingredients.
4 Ounces: 1.99
12 Ounces: 5.95
Salsa Tasting Flight
A flight of 1 ounce tasting samples of each of our five housemade salsas!
2.99

 

Mexitaly!
Italy

Gourmet Brick Oven Pizza

Our crispy thin crust pizza in a non-traditional style. Small personal sized pizza measures 10 inches in diameter, large pizza measures 14 inches in diameter.

The White Pizza
Extra virgin olive oil, garlic, fresh tomatoes and cheese.
Small... 7.99
Large... 11.99
Spicy Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Chipotle pepper sauce, chicken, roasted onions, Jack and cheddar cheese finished with ranch dressing.
Small... 10.99
Large... 15.99
Classic Supreme Pizza
Pepperoni, mushrooms, italian sausage, roasted onions and green peppers.
Small... 11.99
Large... 15.99
Chicken BLT Pizza
Grilled chicken, bacon, Jack & cheddar cheeses, ranch, tomatoes and lettuce.
Small... 11.99
Large... 15.99
Chicken Pesto White Pizza
Grilled Chipotle chicken, fresh pesto, and roasted red peppers.
Small... 11.99
Large... 16.99
Pork BBQ Pizza
Smoky barbeque sauce, Carnitas pork, cheese, and crumbled bleu cheese.
Small... 10.99
Large... 14.99
Chicken BBQ Pizza
Smoky barbeque sauce, grilled chicken, cheese, and crumbled bleu cheese.
Small... 10.99
Large... 14.99
Scampi Pizza
White pizza with shrimp and scallops, roasted red peppers and sundried tomatoes.
Small... 14.99
Large... 19.99
Spanikopita Pizza
Fresh pesto, tomatoes, garlic, fresh spinach and feta cheese.
Small... 11.99
Large... 15.99
Spanikopita Pizza with
Shrimp & Scallops

Fresh pesto, tomatoes, garlic, fresh spinach, feta cheese, topped with a generous portion of shrimp and scallops.
Small... 14.99
Large... 19.99
Mexitaly Pizza
Our signature pizza. Salsa, Chorizo (Mexican sausage), cheese and beans finished with sour cream, guacamole and pico de gallo.
Small... 11.99
Large... 15.99
Pancetta Pepper Pizza
Italian bacon, roasted red peppers and roasted onions on a white pizza.
Small... 11.99
Large... 15.99
Greek Pizza
White pizza with sundried tomatoes, feta cheese, Kalamata olives and artichoke hearts.
Small... 11.99
Large... 15.99
Veggie Supreme Pizza
Onion, green peppers, tomatoes, mushrooms, zucchini, spinach, grilled eggplant and cheese.
Small... 11.99
Large... 15.99
Seafood BBQ Pizza
Smoky barbeque sauce, shrimp and scallops with crispy bacon, Jack and cheddar cheeses.
Small... 14.99
Large... 19.99
Sausage, Sweet Pepper & Roasted Onion Pizza
Italian sausage, roasted peppers and sauteed onions, just like the sub!
Small... 10.99
Large... 14.99

Build Your Own Pizza

Crispy thin crust cheese pizza from our woodstone brick oven. Craft your very own style with our extensive selection of standard, specialty and deluxe pizza toppings.

Personal 10-inch Pizza... 7.99
Add'l. Standard Toppings... 1.19 each
Add'l. Specialty Toppings... 1.99
Add'l. Deluxe Toppings... 2.99
Large 14-inch Pizza... 9.99
Add'l. Standard Toppings... 1.79 each
Add'l. Specialty Toppings... 3.99
Add'l. Deluxe Toppings... 5.99
Standard Toppings
  • Pepperoni
  • Meatballs
  • Ham
  • Italian Sausage
  • Beef
  • Kalamata Olives
  • Housemade Chorizo
  • Genoa Salami
  • Jalapeno
  • Fresh Sauteed Mushrooms
  • Fire-Roasted Onions
  • Roasted Green Peppers
  • Pineapple
  • Tomatoes
  • Sundried Tomatoes
  • Sweet Peppers
  • Spinach
  • Extra Cheese
  • Roasted Garlic
Specialty Toppings
  • Pancetta (Italian Bacon)
  • Anchovies
  • Roasted Red Peppers
  • Pesto
  • Feta Cheese
  • Eggplant
  • Chipotle Chicken
  • Carnitas Pork
  • Seasoned Ground Beef
  • Grilled Zucchini

Deluxe Toppings

  • Southwestern Steak
  • Chipotle Seared Shrimp & Scallops

 

Baked Stromboli

A hefty Italian burrito, baked to perfection. Please note, Stromboli takes between 20 and 25 minutes from time of order to the plate! But good things come to those who wait. Also available in a smaller version for lightweights.

Italian
Baked Stromboli

Pepperoni, ham, italian sausage, cheese and pizza sauce.
9.99
Meatball
Baked Stromboli

Meaty meatballs, fresh made sauce, and cheese.
9.99
Pesto
Baked Stromboli

Grilled chicken, fresh pesto, cheese, mushrooms and sauce.
9.99
Mexiboli
Baked Stromboli

Beans, chicken, chorizo, sour cream, salsa, and cheese.
9.99
Sausage, Sweet Pepper & Roasted Onion
Baked Stromboli

With freshly prepared sauce and cheese.
9.99
Veggie
Baked Stromboli

Eggplant, zucchini, roasted peppers, and onions.
9.99

Deep Fried Stromboli

Same awesome ingredients as above, only we deep fry the Stromboli instead of baking it. Cuts total prep and cooking time down to about 10 minutes. Many of our customers swear by it once they try it. Perhaps you will too?

Italian
Deep Fried Stromboli

Pepperoni, ham, italian sausage, cheese and pizza sauce.
9.99
Meatball
Deep Fried Stromboli

Meaty meatballs, fresh made sauce, and cheese.
9.99
Pesto
Deep Fried Stromboli

Grilled chicken, fresh pesto, cheese, mushrooms and sauce.
9.99
Mexiboli
Deep Fried Stromboli

Beans, chicken, chorizo, sour cream, salsa, and cheese.
9.99
Sausage, Sweet Pepper & Onion
Deep Fried Stromboli

With freshly prepared sauce and cheese.
9.99
Veggie
Deep Fried Stromboli

Eggplant, zucchini, roasted peppers, and onions.
9.99

Entree Size Salads

Made with crisp Romaine lettuce. Substitute Ranch or Spicy Chipotle Ranch dressing.

Italian Salad
Romaine lettuce, tomatoes, onions, cucumbers, ham, salami, and cheese with our freshly made vinaigrette, and served with focaccia Italian bread.
9.99
Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce, focaccia Italian bread, with our freshly made Caesar dressing.
6.99
Pittsburgh Steak Salad
Romaine lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, grilled steak, french fries, cheese with our freshly made dressing.
10.99
Chicken Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce, focaccia, and grilled chicken with our freshly made dressing.
9.99
Greek Salad
Romaine lettuce, tomatoes, onions, cucumber, feta, Kalamata olives, lemon vinaigrette with focaccia Italian break.
8.99
Salmon Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce, focaccia, and seared salmon with our freshly made dressing.
10.99
Extra Dressing... .75
Add Chicken... 3.00
Add Salmon... 4.00
Add bleu cheese crumbles... 1.00
 

Italian Side Dishes

Garlic Breadsticks
Served with freshly made marinara sauce.
5.99
Provolone Sticks
Six sticks, deep fried and served with freshly made marinara sauce.
5.99
Calamari
Deep fried and served with our own ginger garlic sauce.
8.99
Garden Salad
Romaine lettuce, cucumber, onion and tomato topped with grated cheese and your choice of dressing.
3.99
Italian Fries
Topped with Romano cheese.
4.99
Fresh Cut Fries
Made with freshly cut potatoes.
4.99

Mexitaly!
Kid's Menu

Children's Meals

Ages 12 and under. Served with fountain soda or juice box. Substitute bottled Mexican soda for an additional 1.00.

Mini Cheese Pizza
Includes a fountain soda or juice box. Add toppings for .50 each.
5.99
Cheese Quesadilla
Includes a fountain soda or juice box. Add meat for 1.50 additional.
5.99
Spaghetti & Meatball
Smothered in marinara sauce. Includes a fountain soda or juice box.
5.99
 

Flag of MexicoFlag of Italy